Top 2023 MLB Playoff Baseball Rookie Cards to Collect

The 2023 MLB Playoffs are underway and we share some helpful sports card content targeting the top baseball rookie cards to collect. And there are some intriguing sports card collecting opportunities. Trending high with the baseball card community are perennial all-star caliber players including Mookie Betts, Corey Seager, Ronald Acuna Jr(eBay), and other star performers. Corbin Carroll ranks at the top for younger star baseball prospects competing in the 2023 MLB playoffs.

Baseball card collector are showing some “love” to the city of brotherly love as demand for the beloved Philadelphia Phillies is spiking. And why not with the Phillies making some noise in the 2023 MLB playoffs! We see a demand on the rise to collect star Phillie players including Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber, and Nick Castellanos.

No surprise to see Harper and Turner as investment targets for baseball cards to collect. Both are mainstays on the sports card collecting scene. Bryce Harper has enjoyed a nice renaissance for his baseball rookie cards since getting healthy and helping his Phils in 2023.

Baseball card demand has heated up over the past 30 days with the MLB playoffs taking over the attention of sports card collectors. Market Movers reports baseball card collecting demand has increased over the past 30 days. The best performing sports card category over the past 30 days is Baseball (2000-2009) and it’s up 5.7% per Market Pulse reports.

Read on to learn what the best baseball card to collect and that you should be adding to to your sports card investment portfolio!

2019 Corbin Carroll Bowman Rookie Autograph
Corbin Carroll Baseball Cards on eBay

Nick Castellanos

Nick Castellanos is on fire! Nick is an outfielder for the Philadelphia Phillies. He has played with multiple teams including the Detroit Tigers and Cincinnati Reds. Nick was a prized Tiger rookie prospect and was hot with baseball card collectors his rookie year.

As of the 2023 season, Nick has a career batting average of .276 with 1,451 hits, 210 home runs, 762 RBIs, and 675 runs scored. Castellanos was named an All-Star twice and earned a Silver Slugger award. Nick had a breakout 2021 season en route to a number nine MLB Player MVP finish with the Reds. And after a couple years with the Phillies he appears to be reaching next level player performance.

2023 MLB Playoff Historic Performance

Nick Castellanos is the first player in MLB history to hit two home runs in back-to- back MLB playoff games (versus the Atlanta Braves). He then homered again, for good measure, in the first game against the Arizona Diamondbacks.

The Phillies lineup is absolutely loaded with strong bats including Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber, J.T. Realmuto and other young hitters! In this star studded hitting lineup it’s easy to see why Castellanos is taking his game to the next level.

Over the past 14 days Castellanos’ 2014 Topps Chrome #4 Rookie Autograph card has surged up the index. The card has showed a consistent 25%+ increase in value with a 126% increase for the PSA 10 base auto version. We don’t see this trend ending. Especially if the Phillies move onto the 2023 World Series.

If you haven’t started. It’s time to start collecting Nick Castellanos baseball cards. Castellanos is a strong BTC strong sports card investment to buy now and heading into 2024.

Best Nick Castellanos Rookie Baseball Cards to Collect

Click to Find Best Nick Castellanos Rookie Cards to Collect Now

Max Scherzer

Max Scherzer has been a dominant pitcher throughout his illustrious career. He’s been an active player in MLB since 2008 and has played for teams such as the Arizona Diamondbacks, Detroit Tigers, Washington Nationals, Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Mets, and currently with the Texas Rangers. As of the 2023 season, he has a career win-loss record of 214-108 with an earned run average (ERA) of 3.15 and 3,367 strikeouts.

Scherzer is an eight-time MLB All-Star, has won three Cy Young Awards, has pitched two no-hitters, and won the World Series with the Nationals in 2019. Max is also known for his intensity and competitiveness on the field and is fondly nicknamed “Mad Max” after the film series of the same name.

Over the past 30 days Scherzer’s PSA 9 2008 Topps Update #UH280 Rookie card has risen in value. The baseball rookie card has increased in price value from $39 to $117. That’s a 194% change and increase in baseball card value. This is a solid, stable long-term Scherzer card to add to your sports card collecting portfolio.

Max Scherzer is likely a first ballot MLB Hall of Famer that we’re watching now. Baseball card collectors should continue to add Scherzer cards to their collection.

Most Valuable Max Scherzer Panini & Topps Baseball Cards to Collect

These elite Max Scherzer Panini & Topps PSA Baseball Cards cards are valued at just under $1000 up to $5000.

  • 2008 Stadium Club Max Scherzer RC #173 Autograph PSA 8
  • 2008 Bowman(eBay) Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects Max Scherzer RC #BDP33 PSA 8.5
  • 2007 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Collegiate Patches Autograph Max Scherzer #CP-MS #/182 PSA 9
  • 2008 SPx Rookie Signatures Max Scherzer RC #150 Autograph PSA 9

Click to Find Best Max Scherzer Baseball Cards to Collect Now

Corbin Carroll

Corbin Carroll is a young and talented outfielder in the Arizona Diamondbacks organization. His baseball cards are highly sought after by collectors and his rookie card values continue to increase.

One of the sports card performance factors we look at are honors, awards, and recognition. These predictive factors play a large role in affecting and projecting sports card values. The MLB Rookie of the Year Award is one of these predictive factors we incorporate into our analysis.

Carroll has been raking all season and large reason why the Diamondbacks are still competing in the 2023 MLB playoffs. Carroll has distanced hinself in the 2023 MLB ROY award and currently a -10000 favorite to win the award.

Corbin has been gaining considerable momentum with sports card collectors. His recent card values have spiked up in value and sell briskly.

2023 MLB Rookie of the Year Odds


MLB RookieOdds (BetMGM)
 Corbin Carroll-10000
 Matt McLain+15000
 Cade Cavalli+2000
 Kodai Senga+1400
 Elly De La Cruz+10000
 Francisco Alvarez+4000
 Garrett Mitchell+2500
 Spencer Steer+15000


Gunnar Henderson is the clear favorite to win for the AL at -5000 Odds.

 Gunnar Henderson-5000
 Logan O’Hoppe+2000
 Josh Jung(eBay)+5000

Best Corbin Carroll Baseball Rookie Card

Here are some of Corbin Carroll’s top rookie cards.

Carroll has really established himself as a blossoming MLB superstar! Corbin Carroll rookie cards are a leading sports card investment for 2023 and heading into 2024. Start collecting Carroll sports cards now.

Search Best Corbin Carroll Rookie Cards to Collect

Thanks for checking out our helpful sports card content for finding the top 2023 MLB Playoff Baseball Cards to Collect.

Happy collecting!